Best Milkshake in NYC
When it comes to milkshakes in New York City, Harlem Shake® keeps it classic.
Known for handcrafted burgers, fries, and old-school diner vibes, Harlem Shake® has also built a loyal following for what many consider the best milkshakes in NYC. Thick, creamy, and made with real ingredients, these shakes are all about flavor, nostalgia, and doing things the right way.
With two NYC locations, one in historic Harlem and one in Brooklyn on Sterling Place, Harlem Shake® is a go-to stop whether you’re uptown, downtown, or anywhere in between.
Classic Milkshakes, Made the Harlem Shake® Way
Every Harlem Shake® milkshake starts with quality ingredients and zero shortcuts.
We use organic NY fresh whole milk from Organic Valley and organic Blue Marble Ice Cream, a New York favorite known for rich flavor and smooth texture. From there, we build shakes that feel familiar, satisfying, and just indulgent enough.
Some flavors keep it simple. Others lean into bold combinations. All of them are made to be thick, spoon-worthy, and worth the trip.
Milkshake Menu Highlights
Harlem Shake®’s milkshake menu blends diner classics with a few signature twists. Whether you’re in the mood for something traditional or a little more playful, there’s a shake that fits.
Classic Favorites
- Vanilla
- Chocolate
- Strawberry
- Cookies & Cream
Flavor Favorites
- Salted Caramel
- Mocha
- Peanut Butter
- Hazelnut
- Pistachio
- Mango
Signature Shake
- The Harlem Shake® — our red velvet milkshake made with real cake and a cult following to match.
Each shake is made to order and pairs perfectly with a burger and fries.
Two NYC Locations, Twice the Flavor
No matter which Harlem Shake® you visit, the milkshakes are always made the same way — with care, quality ingredients, and a nod to classic American diners.
Harlem
Our original location, rooted in Harlem and full of character. A longtime favorite for locals and visitors looking for great food, great shakes, and an unmistakable New York feel.
Brooklyn
Located on Sterling Place, our Brooklyn shop brings the same menu and energy to a neighborhood setting. Relaxed, welcoming, and just as serious about milkshakes as the original.
Both locations serve the same handcrafted milkshakes that have helped define Harlem Shake®.
Why Harlem Shake®’s Milkshakes Stand Out in NYC
Harlem Shake® milkshakes are made to feel like the real thing, not overly sweet, not artificial, and never thin.
They’re:
- Thick enough for a spoon
- Smooth from first sip to last
- Balanced in flavor
- Made with real dairy and real ingredients
From fruit-forward shakes to dessert-inspired favorites, every option is built on the same foundation: quality ingredients and simple execution done right.
That consistency is what keeps people coming back and why Harlem Shake® continues to be mentioned among the best milkshake spots in NYC.
More Than Milkshakes: The Full Harlem Shake® Experience
Harlem Shake® is known for its shakes, but the full experience is what makes it special.
Expect:
- Classic diner-inspired spaces
- A laid-back, neighborhood feel
- Burgers and fries that hold their own next to the shakes
- A place that works just as well for a quick stop as it does for a long hang
Whether you’re grabbing a shake on its own or pairing it with a meal, Harlem Shake® is built for comfort food moments done right.
About Harlem Shake®
Harlem Shake® started with a simple goal: serve great burgers, fries, and shakes using real ingredients and a lot of personality.
What began in Harlem grew into a New York favorite by sticking to the basics — quality beef, organic dairy, classic recipes, and a welcoming atmosphere. The Brooklyn location continues that tradition, bringing the same menu, mindset, and energy to a new neighborhood.
Harlem Shake® isn’t about trends. It’s about doing classic American food well and creating a place people want to come back to.
Learn more about our story here
Final Scoop: Is Harlem Shake® the Best Milkshake in NYC?
If you’re searching for the best milkshake in NYC, Harlem Shake® delivers exactly what you’re hoping for — classic flavors, real ingredients, and shakes that feel timeless.
Whether you’re visiting Harlem or Brooklyn, the recipe stays the same: keep it simple, make it right, and enjoy every sip. So next time someone asks you “Where can I get the best milkshake in NYC?”, you’ll know where to send them — right here, to Harlem Shake®.
